Author: Imogen Hildred

CNZ v. Royal Bath Hospitals NHS FT and SoS for Health and Social Care, 11 January 2023 Mr Justice Ritchie has given judgment for the claimant in a historic CP case which has significant implications both for Montgomery and material contribution causation in clinical negligence cases, particularly those involving acute profound hypoxic ischaemia. The Claimant, […]

Read More… from Major new decision on Montgomery and causation in Birth Injury Cases

I wrote an article in June last year on material contribution after the case of Davies v Frimley Health NHSFT 2021 EWHC 169 QB. Since then another first instance judge has again expressed obiter remarks on the topic in the case of Thorley v Sandwell and West Birmingham NHS Trust 2021 EWHC 2604 QB. Like Davies, the judge in Thorley also expressed […]

Read More… from Is material contribution restricted to divisible injuries?

Summary: The High Court has today handed down judgment in Marc Traylor and Kitanna Traylor v Kent and Medway NHS Social Care Partnership Trust, a clinical negligence case full of interesting legal issues including the application of the illegality doctrine, voluntary assumption of risk, contributory negligence and Human Rights Act claims.  Although the claims ultimately failed, the […]

Read More… from Insanity should not be equated with illegality: Traylor v Kent and Medway NHS Social Care Partnership Trust [2022] EWHC 260 (QB)

Today, 13 January 2022, the Court of Appeal handed down judgment in the long awaited nervous shock appeals in Paul v Wolverhampton, Polmear v Royal Cornwall and Purchase v Ahmed. The issue was whether a gap in time between the breach of duty and a subsequent shocking event prevents a nervous shock claim. As the Court of Appeal recognised […]

Read More… from Bring on the Supremes…

The determination of life expectation in cerebral palsy litigation must always be driven by the expert evidence in the particular case. What is set out below is an approach driven by the evidence received from experts in reported decisions, but – be warned – great care must always be taken to ensure that in each […]

Read More… from Life Expectancy in Cerebral Palsy cases: The mechanism behind the crystal ball